"Tolle Lege" - Augustine's famous garden conversion, in a later, fanciful rendering
Following up on a previous post, this is something I cooked up while working as a “preceptor” at Duke–that is, leading seminars for students taking a course (in this case Dr. David Steinmetz’s CH13: Church History to the Reformation), in which we interacted in more depth with the primary documents.
This one’s on that Great Brain of the early church, Augustine of Hippo. It includes a few “notes to myself” about how to lead such a seminar, since as a doctoral student I was still wet behind the ears on this important matter of pedagogy. I wish I could remember which sourcebook we were using for the Augustine quotations. I could go try to figure it out from old syllabi, if anyone’s interested:
A pronunciation suggestion
One of the first and most basic problems we have to deal with when we talk about this great North African theologian is this: [write on board] Is it AUG-us-teen or au-GUS-tin? It makes no difference to me which we say, but somewhere along the way, I was told that if you want to make it at a party with a bunch of church historians, you need to use au-GUS-tin for this man from Hippo, and reserve AUG-us-teen for the archbishop installed in England by the Pope around the year 600, who tried to bring the Celtic [or is that SSSeltic?] church into line.
In any case, it doesn’t matter to me how we pronounce it today. Saying AUG-us-teen won’t lower your grade…much.
Getting into Augustine’s thought:
1. Write on the board: “posse non peccare,” “non posse non peccare,” “non posse peccare.”
2. Start with the background from Latourette, to put Augustine in context with (1) the E/W distinctions S. has made, (2) some other “fathers,” (3) Augustine’s own personal history.
3. Deal with quoted sections from Augustine, below, one by one, allowing conversation to develop as it will. If this serves to jumpstart the process of “dealing with Augustine on freedom,” well and good. I needn’t return to the quotations. If things slow down, however, I can reopen with, “what about this statement: [quotation]. What is Augustine saying here and what do we think about it?”
4. Throughout the process, resist going too far off into either what we think about Augustine (though that’s inevitable) or, especially, whether Wesley (Calvin, Luther, Joe Blow) would have agreed with Augustine. It is OK to do this now and again, but as in a Bible study, let’s return to the text. We need to discipline ourselves to do that because it is often so much easier to talk about our own opinions or those of our church traditions, than to confront and work through the thought of the person we are studying.
5. For the second half (or third, or quarter, or last five minutes) of the class, survey Augustine’s thought on (1) the status, (2) person, (3) and work of Christ, as well as (4) the Holy Spirit, (5) the Trinity, (6) the Church, (7) the Sacraments, and (8) the Last Things. Continue reading